Category: Library cooperation

  • The fight for fair eBook pricing for libraries: an insider view on legislative advocacy

    Introduction

    I have been a volunteer with the Illinois Library Association’s Public Policy Committee since 2023. This committee provides the association’s focus on legislative matters for all libraries in Illinois. During my time as committee chair in 2025, our committee introduced legislation to help libraries with the high costs of eBooks and e-content.

    How did we arrive at this moment?

    eBooks & e-Audiobooks are not free for libraries

    Typically, this is a surprise when explained to the public. Libraries are not the creators or stewards of eBooks within their public programs. Libraries do not control the contract terms of the of the eBook platforms in the areas of lending and price. The public is mostly familiar with the eBook app Libby, but they know little about the strict controls in place dictating price and lending.

    In the lead up to my time on the Public Policy Committee, my discussions with public library directors on trends within their services began noting the huge increase in costs for eBooks from a collection budget perspective, with e-content platforms taking up 50% of their collection budget.

    I researched this further within Institute for Museum and Library Services public library data, and found that overall that eBook circulation for libraries was 20% of the total circulation, with the 80% circulation being the tradition physical collections. What was causing half of libraries collection budget going to only 20% of its total circulation?

    Public libraries are seeing upwards of a 200% increase over last 10 years for eBook titles. In fact, it is growing worse for eAudiobook titles where libraries are charged 3.4 time more for audio titles than the cost the public pays for the same title. The cost for eBooks is 3.9 times more than what the public pays.

    Many academic libraries are zeroing out their physical book budgets to afford electronic resources to journals and eBooks.

    On top of this, libraries never get to own these titles. They must be renewed after 26 checkouts (or 52 checkouts depending). We only have the right to loan, not the right to own these titles. Libraries can only “own” if a perpetual license is offered, which is not often.

    Public library users are frustrated by long hold queues. What they do not know is on top of these licensing terms and high costs is a limit to lending: one copy, one user is the most common use permitted.

    Why is legislation necessary?

    Illinois Library Association Public Policy Committee annually solicits legislative ideas from its statewide membership. The committee received a proposal for eBook pricing legislation in years prior, and again in 2025. The goal of the proposal was Illinois libraries want fair contracts and reasonable costs. Illinois taxpayers ultimately are footing the bill for the high eBook pricing, so libraries want to be good fiscal stewards of these dollars and make their budgets go further.

    Illinois is not alone in this legislative effort. Connecticut signed eBook legislation into law in May 2025. Rhode Island passed eBook pricing legislation in June 2026, and Washington DC passed passed a similar bill in May 2026. New Jersey has introduced similar legislation through Senate S4520.

    So there are multiple states pursuing or have passed legislation pertaining to high eBook costs for libraries from a consumer protection and contract law perspective.

    Illinois Digital Library Protection Act

    Illinois House Bill 5236 is also grounded in Illinois consumer protection and contract law. It regulates contract terms, and does not mandate publisher behavior. In practice, it applies to new contracts and renewals of contracts, and is not retroactive. It prohibits violations of the Protection Act as unlawful under Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act, and enforcement authority is granted to the Illinois Attorney General.

    Our legislative advocacy effort

    Libraries traditionally have great relationships with their local legislators. We often host events and programs spearheaded by local legislators, and library support is overwhelmingly bipartisan.

    If we were going push for support of the legislation, we had a solid foundation for advocating in support of the bill. We knew there would be pushback, but we also knew that our “ask” was not unreasonable: this was a taxpayer issue!

    Infographics & one-page handouts

    Infographics convey complex information quickly so we used these extensively throughout our legislative advocacy effort. We varied these by audience: some for the public, some for libraries, some for legislators themselves.

    Bill sponsor & committee testimony

    Illinois legislation was crafted with the help of the eBook Study Group, a non-profit organization led by a self-assembled, largely volunteer, small group of librarians, attorneys, and library advocates from various non-profit organizations. Our model legislation was developed by Kyle K. Courtney, a copyright lawyer and librarian, co-founder of Library Futures and the eBook Study Group.

    Much credit goes to our bill sponsor, Representative Tracy Katz Muhl for submitting HB5236, the Digital Library Protection Act. Representative Katz Muhl and the Illinois Library Association lobbyist helped guide us with the process of preparing for testimony when the bill was called for a hearing at the Consumer Protection Committee. We prepared for testimony through coordinating three librarians and one local author, knowing in advance that legislative hearings can be a busy affair and to be prepared that we might only be allotted time for one person to testify. But we had our stories ready! Large and small libraries being impacted by high eBook costs, and local authors wanting to see more back listed eBook titles be purchased by libraries instead of collection budgets being consumed only by the most popular eBook titles.

    HB5236 was assigned with a hearing scheduled for March 24, 2026 at 4:00 p.m. We traveled across the state and arrived at Springfield to testify in support of the legislation. Our bill sponsor nimbly led us through the hearing and we were successful in getting HB5236 passed out of committee.

    HB 5236 Approved by the Illinois House 99-0

    On April 17, 2026, it was brought to the House floor for a third reading. After a short debate, HB5236 passed unanimously, 99-0!

    Local news coverage

    The local news picked up our success in the House and began publishing stories about the legislation. This effort was in fact a specific part of our legislative strategy: to keep the legislation in the news during the summer of 2026 while we prepared for the advocacy push in the Senate.

    Front page of the Tuesday, April 23, 2026 Chicago Tribune print version: “Illinois bill would stop publishers from charging libraries more than public for e-books and audiobooks” Online version: “New bill has libraries wanting to be heard”

    Kate Hall, executive director of the Northbrook Public Library, said the current system limits the number of books people can find while forcing libraries to repeatedly repurchase the same titles. With more money to work with, Hall and other librarians said they would look to expand their libraries’ digital book collection. For patrons, Hall said this would mean shorter hold times with libraries able to purchase more copies and more books from mid-level authors.

    xxxx

    Publisher FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt)

    Journalists will make sure to obtain perspectives on both sides of an issue, and within the Tribune article there were quotes from The Authors Guild and Association of American Publishers CEOs.

    “Author and publisher associations say the bill puts the economic livelihood of the people whose books fill library shelves in jeopardy…
    “Digital access thrives nationwide today, and this bill threatens to undermine, not increase, digital access for library patrons. When publishers cannot comply with the bill’s extreme and restrictive mandates, libraries risk losing access to digital books entirely,” Association of American Publishers CEO Maria Pallante and The Authors Guild CEO Mary Rasenberger said in a joint statement. “Authors, independent bookstores, and artists across music, film, and literature all depend on the licensing framework this legislation attempts to dismantle to protect them from piracy and safeguard the modest promise of remuneration for their work.”

    Note that “libraries risk losing access to digital books entirely,”according to AAP and The Authors Guild. Why would libraries lose access? The more likely scenario is publishers would embargo libraries, rather than adhere to fair pricing.

    The scare tactics being used by the publishing industry to push back on the bill is one that I was familiar with in the open source software area called FUD: fear, uncertainty, doubt.

    The opposition to the bill also often cite it was a violation of copyright, or that it was “extreme” despite the fact the bill was created with consumer protection as its guideposts.

    Outreach in the Senate

    HB5236 is currently under legal review with the Senate General Counsel, but we hope that our bill will be assigned to a committee when the Senate returns to session in the fall. My advocacy efforts continue with the Illinois Library Association and our group of incredible volunteers. We believe our legislation will help our largest libraries– Chicago Public Library– to our smallest libraries in the state, as well as our libraries in higher education and our school libraries with cost effective and fair access to resources needed for research and the enjoyment of reading.

  • Aspen: forming a community of governance

    “An aspen tree is not an individual tree; all trees in an aspen grove have common roots and a shared genetic code. Just like an aspen tree, libraries using Aspen have a shared software code base and support one another in their ideas and examples.” Mark Noble, creator of Aspen

    Aspen is a suite of library software that started with the flagship Discovery and now includes additional modules such as the LiDA mobile app (Library Discovery Application) and Web Builder. As of 2025, Aspen is in use by more than 2,800 libraries worldwide and is supported by a community of hundreds of librarians.

    A bevy of vendors have come together to support and develop Aspen– Bywater Solutions, Equinox, Grove for Libraries, Open-Fifth, and Theke Solutions among the top contributors.

    I became involved with Aspen through my role as Executive Director at SWAN, which conducted an evaluation of the solution in 2019 and a pilot project in 2020. SWAN contracted with ByWater Solutions for support and development of the pilot, while SWAN hosted the system in its own cloud environment. SWAN outlined in May 2020 that the purpose of the pilot was an “Evaluation-based implementation of the Aspen discovery tool to integrate with the SirsiDynix Symphony ILS, providing select patrons and member libraries an alternative to the current Enterprise catalog interface. The evaluation will demonstrate the prospects of the Aspen Discovery tool in meeting the concerns of the Membership regarding discovery issues.”

    The pilot lasted a full year and included configuring e-content integration for 7 libraries and SWAN sponsored software development with Mark Noble at ByWater. Several features were required in order for SWAN to consider a switch, the first of being integration with SWAN’s Symphony ILS which had never been done before, integration with EBSCO Discovery Service, and many web accessibility enhancements. The software development went very smoothly, with additional enhancements arriving with monthly releases of Aspen Discovery.

    After the pilot phase it was decided that Aspen Discovery was ready for full adoption by the 100 libraries in SWAN.

    A Need for Community Governance

    Fast forward from 2021 to 2024, it was clear that the open source project Aspen was a growing success and that it needed a structure for setting strategic direction and decision making.

    I reached out to 7 individuals within the community and invited them for a discussion on creating a governance structure within written bylaws and deciding what type of legal entity should Aspen be formed under.

    Our first set of meetings were exercises to answer the following questions.

    • What is the Aspen community?
    • What are catastrophes that would have a significant impact on the Aspen project?
    • What different types of governance for an open-source project exist?
    • What was the experience of other library open source projects?
    Organizational view of the Aspen Community
    Organizational view of the Aspen Community: result from the exercise “Who is your community?”

    Throughout this initial series of Aspen governance task force meetings, the resources provided by Lyrasis “It Takes a Village: Open Source Software Sustainability” were invaluable. It Takes a Village is a toolkit for “practical use in planning and managing sustainability for open source software (OSS) initiatives.” We invited Laurie Arp, Laurie Arp, Senior Director, Community Supported Technologies and Hosting Services, Lyrasis, to speak about the toolkit and we shared its impact to-date on our efforts.

    Catastrophizing

    One significant exercise from It Takes a Village was to conduct a brainstorming session to generate a list of “catastrophes” that would have a significant impact on Aspen’s ability to fulfill its mission.

    Catastrophizing: Miro board results from Aspen Governance Task Force activity on potential catastrophes befalling the open source project

    The exercise resulted in the following potential negative scenarios:

    • Forking the code
    • Security breaches, data encryption and privacy concerns
    • Expertise being too centralized
    • Keeping a stable vision of the Aspen project
    • Lack of funding

    “Forking the code” was noted as not necessarily a bad thing, as Aspen was in fact built upon a fork of the VuFind codebase, but that a code fork would split the community and dilute potential resources.

    Once the potential negative outcomes were established, we had a common set of issues to address through our design of community governance.

    Understanding sustainable open source models

    The RedHat Blog “Understanding open source models” served as an initial discussion on models under which open source software projects operate.

    We discussed the different governance models described, focusing on the benevolent dictator, meritocracy, delegate, and dynamic governance models. Members of the task force involved with software development expressed a preference for the meritocracy model, while others cited the need for controlled delegation within the benevolent dictator model, which was also critiqued for a lack of sustainability as it relies on a single individual. There were concerns raised about the potential for founder syndrome to hinder the growth of the organization. It was generally agreed that some of these models might not be suitable for their current stage, but ultimately were models for how software development could be organized within the Aspen project, and not the governance per se.

    The task force explored options to incorporate the legal entity under, including the Software Freedom Conservancy, the potential of using a 501(c)(3), and the Open Library Foundation.

    For Aspen, the nearest sibling open source project within the library community was the Evergreen Project, which had originally incorporated under the Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC), and then after a period of establishment, moved to incorporate under the 501(c)(3). Members of the Evergreen Project community were interviewed and the experiences of building its governance, relationship with SFC, and development of its bylaws were presented.

    Ultimately it was decided that forming Aspen governance under a foundation would provide the legal, financial, and technical support required for a fledgling library open source project. The required steps from the Open Library Foundation were presented and the project milestones for finalizing governance were established.

    Creation of Aspen bylaws

    With the Evergreen Project bylaws serving as a model, it was decided to name our project “Aspen Library Software Foundation.” It was proposed that the board composition be only members of the community that were not employees of the companies involved with Aspen. This was, of course, a controversial proposition. Discussion within the task force naturally split between vendors wanting a presence on the governing board and those that wanted to establish clear separation between the software developers and the community of libraries. It was decided that the Aspen project should remain firmly in the hands of the library community and the “vendor ban” be put in place within the governing board structure.

    Community feedback & clarification

    The Aspen community meets monthly to review notably software development features and to provide updates from the groups of volunteers working on projects such as bug tracking and planning the annual conference. The governance task force provided updates to the community throughout the year and brought forward the draft of the bylaws and recommendation to apply for legal status under the OLF. The feedback obtained was helpful in providing explanations of the structure of the board and standing committees under the bylaws, particularly the Technical Committee under which the software developers from various companies and libraries would set direction and make decisions.

    We conducted community endorsement vote where approval was overwhelmingly positive. This was followed by a collection of nominations for governing board, which already had a project slate defined to complete the required steps to join the OLF.

    Conclusion

    The Aspen Library Software Foundation nine member board was seated November 17, 2025. I myself decided to not participate on the Aspen governing board as I had other projects underway as my role on the Illinois Library Association Public Policy Committee expanded to be the Chair for the 2025-2026 legislative season.

  • How libraries & consortia can build a sustainable future

    The International Coalition of Library Consortia issued a report in September 2022 which outlines the challenges facing libraries pertaining to technology, access to information, and strategic direction.

    I have been involved with the International Coalition of Library Consortia (ICOLC) task force for a full year and helped with the evolution of the ideas and strategies within its written report. I recently wrote an article summarizing the report, and this piece is now published in the January 2023 Journal of Library Administration.

    The concerns of the task force can be summarized in the following:

    • The rising cost of accessing and curating digital knowledge, coupled with shrinking budgets, political and institutional challenges, and multiple staffing issues facing the profession, mean that ever-increasing system costs impose unsustainable burdens on many—if not all—libraries.
    • Libraries have collectively turned responsibility over to a new and growing industry of companies with expertise in delivering solutions for library needs. These solutions were largely proprietary, with library funds thus flowing into a corporate-controlled marketplace.
    • As market consolidation has taken place, libraries have few options for responding to the changing needs and expectations of end-users.

    The Way Forward

    For libraries to accomplish their missions, serve their users, and effectively steward limited resources, libraries of all types must be able to select the services, platforms, and technology providers that match organizational values and meet both long- and short-term needs.

    The 2.5% Commitment graphic

    To that end, we argue that libraries must empower themselves by reestablishing agency and reasserting control over the technical infrastructure critical to libraries’ success.

    We call on library administrators to evaluate their existing infrastructure costs, dependence on corporate entities, and associated risks, and to consider adopting one or more of the strategies outlined in the report.

    Our recommendations

    1. The ICOLC report outlines what libraries should do differently in their ongoing relationships with vendors and the open-source community.
    2. Suggest alternatives to the typical library/vendor model, especially open-source/community-owned efforts that address the needs outlined in the report.
    3. Articulate a broad vision for how these efforts tie together and provide a framework for libraries to support these projects.
      1. Radically rethink our operations to build the future we need.
      2. Reframe contracts for proprietary services.
      3. Design, support, & fund alternative solutions now.

    Library-created solutions are important and central to the way forward.

  • ILA poster session

    The three images below are the graphics created for the ILA 2022 Conference poster session presentation. You can read the full article on the Three Pillars published on this site.

    ILA Poster - ILLINET
    ILLINET is the foundation on which resource sharing for Illinois libraries is built upon
    ILA Poster - Delivery
    Cooperation between Illinois libraries created the statewide catalog & maintaining that online platform continues with 6 Illinois library consortia
    ILA Poster - Library Consortia
    Poster #3: Library consortia & the statewide resource sharing platform utilizing OCLC WorldCat & WorldShare
  • My OCLC Global Council Statement

    The OCLC global council election will run from September 20, 2021 through October 1, 2021. I was accepted as a candidate. You can read all the candidate statements on the OCLC page dedicated to the 2021 slate. I have included my full candidate statement below.

    Biography – Please compose your professional profile, which will be used to promote your candidacy if you are selected by your Regional Council Nominating Committee.

    I have 22 years library experience with 12 years’ experience as Executive Director of the SWAN Libraries resource sharing consortium. Leading a library consortium has allowed me to become experienced in all facets of library services. I have always welcomed the challenge of providing solutions for the immediate needs of libraries, all the while retaining a wider view of how libraries can strive to meet the next challenge. 

    Why is membership in the OCLC cooperative important to you and your institution? 

    Integrating libraries within the regional, national, and global presence is critical for libraries as their presence is increasingly an online presence. OCLC’s WorldCat bibliographic holdings and central index of online resources provides libraries the heavyweight fighter needed in the world of big tech. Our SWAN library consortium relies on OCLC services and shared bibliographic resources throughout all processes of library automation, including cataloging, extended worldwide discovery, and resource sharing. Effective configuration, training, and support for our member libraries in these services have enabled our libraries to respond to any patron request knowing that the extended network is accessible and willing to share resources and expertise.

    Please explain why you want to be a delegate and describe the contributions you would like to make to the Global and Regional Councils to promote global cooperation and OCLC membership. 

    OCLC has the technology and the tools for libraries to thrive and be successful. I believe the OCLC messaging to public libraries is somewhat lost within the battle for library staff and leadership attention. To take advantage of OCLC services, libraries need to be proactive in seeking training and support. In libraries of all sizes, staff are stretched thin. It is difficult to keep up with new tools and enhancement of services. I believe library systems, consortia, and networking groups can help share this knowledge and support within their membership circles. We have implemented a new tier of support in our 100-member library consortium to integrate OCLC configuration, support, training, and value-added services for members. It took some effort to get the initial configurations established. This effort has been well worth the benefits of extended services to our patrons and expansion of tools, resources, and expertise demonstrated daily by library staff throughout our consortium. 

    I would champion the collaborative work of libraries in developing tools through the developer network and encourage more active work in this area. SWAN staff, working in collaboration with other Illinois library consortium and the teams at OCLC, developed a service to update large consortium holdings in OCLC. The OCLC Holdings Manager (OHM) is shared in GitHub and works with a group-level web services key to update holdings across 6 consortia in Illinois. This is representative of work that can be accomplished in collaboration with other libraries and the OCLC team.

    Please describe your leadership responsibilities within your library. Include relevant library data (e.g., size of collection, number of branches, number of staff, etc.). 

    I am the Executive Director of SWAN Libraries, an enterprise library consortium of 100 libraries in Illinois. SWAN serves 1.2 million registered library users and contains 1.5 million unique items in its catalog. SWAN circulates 19.5 million annually, making it the one of the busiest library technology platforms in the United States. Under my watch, SWAN has expanded library resource sharing through the addition of 25 libraries over the past five years, growing from 75 to 100 members strong. I have overseen multiple strategic planning initiatives and executed their accompanying tactical plans.

    Please list any professional affiliations (e.g., member of a consortium, a library association, etc.) and contributions you have made to local, regional, or global library communities. 

    Illinois Library Association, Nominating Committee, 2015-2016

    Future of Resource Sharing Committee, Illinois State Library, 2011-2012

    RAILS Board Consortia Committee, Reaching Across Illinois Library System, 2012 – present

    Illinois Library Association, Member

    American Library Association, Member

    What other relevant information, if any, would you like to share with your Regional Council Nominating Committee?

    SWAN has built a tool to help maintain for our Illinois library resource sharing consortium the OCLC Holdings Manager (OHM). The purpose of OHM is to ensure Illinois libraries collections are accurately reflected in WorldCat, but it could be used by any library or organization. The OHM tool is designed to set the library collection holdings for millions of records within OCLC, ensuring large shared bibliographic databases are synchronized with OCLC WorldCat. OHM relies on OCLC WorldCat Metadata API. It was designed for consortia but will work for single libraries. 

    This work was completed with the assistance of Bruce Crocco, OCLC Vice President – Library Services for the Americas, OCLC consultants, and input from individuals at the Resource Sharing Alliance, Pinnacle Library Cooperative, Cooperative Computer Services, PrairieCat, and Illinois Heartland Library System SHARE. The tool is freely available on SWAN’s Github for libraries to download and install or enhance and contribute to its code base. 

    https://github.com/SWAN-Library-Services/OCLC-Holdings-Manager